|
NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH Send This Review to a Friend
Director Rod Lurie’s “Nothing But the Truth,” a strong thematic movie shown at the 2008 Toronto International Film Festival and now going into commercial release (in Manhattan Dec. 17 at E-Walk), stars Kate Beckinsale as a journalist who goes to jail rather than expose the source that set her onto a story outing a woman as a C.I.A. agent. It is fictional, but clearly brings to mind the real recent case under the Bush Administration of C.I.A. agent Valerie Plame and the imprisonment of then New York Times writer Judith Miller after she refused to name her source.
But this new film triumphs as its own original story, and it is a powerful one that stacks up among the best films of the year. The screenwriting by director Lurie is smart, the action is well plotted, and the performances, starring and supporting, are commanding.
Let’s start with Beckinsale as Rachel Armstrong. I have admired her acting since I saw her in a film titled “Cold Comfort Farm.” She has done much work since, but this tops everything. She is utterly convincing in one of the year’s best performances and at times heartbreaking in delineating this portrait of a married woman and mother, a person of conviction whose life is turned upside down because she refuses to bend before the pressures applied after she does what she believes is her journalistic duty of writing an expose article for a Washington, D.C. daily newspaper.
Her nemesis, a tough-minded prosecutor determined to break her so that she reveals those who leaked the information to her is played to the hilt by Matt Dillon as Patton Dubois in a strident masterly performance that dramatizes the stakes involved.
Vera Farmiga has an award-caliber supporting actress turn as Erica Van Doren, the C.I.A. agent who is also a mother and whose child goes to the same school as Rachel’s child. When exposed, Erica is trapped between the unscrupulous authorities for whom she has worked and who have their own agenda, and the consequences of suddenly becoming a high-profile public figure.
Angela Bassett provides yet another effective acting job as Bonnie Benjamin, the newspaper editor who stands behind Erica as the pressure mounts. Veteran actor Alan Alda adds a note of class as Erica’s hot-shot attorney Albert Burnside, who takes pride in the fancy suits he wears and in his success, but also believes in his client’s rights, feels for her as a human being and wants to make sure she knows the score of what’s involved. There’s a particularly intriguing bit of casting involving Floyd Abrams, who is a top First Amendment lawyer in real life (he was co-counsel for the New York Times in the landmark Pentagon Papers case), and here, playing against type, does a convincing job portraying the judge who orders Erica incarcerated until she talks.
The cast also includes David Schwimmer as Ray, Rachel’s husband whose loyalty is put to the test by her willingness to go to prison no matter the cost to their relationship. The expertise with which the above mentioned roles are handled is further reflected in other casting, and in the general atmosphere of reality, whether in a newspaper office, courtroom or prison.
There may be some quarrelling with the film’s ending. “Nothing But the Truth” is a highly political film that taps into the issues of government abuse and individual conscience in a manner that makes it extremely important in light of what has happened through the years of the most recent administration. But even beyond that freedom of the press is an historical issue and one that doesn’t die. However, there are viewers who may want the film to be even more political that it is.
Let’s be grateful for what we have. This is a bold, meaningful film by Lurie, who obviously likes to make himself heard with movies that have something to say, as was the case with his earlier “The Contender.” He has served up a dandy with “Nothing But the Truth,” which I appreciate far more than some of the highly touted year-end releases that trade on star power and heavy marketing but at their core are vapid. “Nothing But the Truth” is the real stuff.

|